These people did Halloween right, but ultimately, it just wasn’t good enough.

1. Zombie Bride and Groom

Dave and Lauren wowed their friends with their super realistic zombie bride and groom costumes. Unfortunately, their outfits didn’t help with Dave’s commitment issues, as he admitted being “kind of freaked out” by seeing Lauren in a wedding dress.

2. Bob and Linda Belcher from Bob’s Burgers

As Lindsey and Ed found out, planning a great Halloween costume together does not compensate for a complete lack of physical chemistry.

3. American Gothic

This costume started out with lofty ambitions of being a totally kick-ass couple’s costume, but the wheels came off when Kristen told Seth that she wanted to see other people while they were picking out a pitchfork at Home Depot. The costume ended up turning out well. Kristen and Seth did not.

4. Lucille Ball and Ricky Ricardo from I Love Lucy

What an adorable I Love Lucy costume! This is the last picture ever taken of Todd and Andrea together.

5. Wayne and Garth from Wayne’s World

Things were not so “party time” or “excellent” during the six-hour screaming match Jacob and Rita unleashed at Halloween Bonanza while shopping for these Wayne’s World costumes.